Which Sportsbook Is the Best for Home Run Betting? We Find Out
Not all sportsbooks are equal when it comes to betting home runs. But which is the best value for your money? We find out.

Having the right resources and being well-informed are essential for success as a sports bettor, but that's just one piece of the puzzle.
Using the best betting sites is equally important to ensure you get the most value from your plays.
It's helpful to approach betting like a consumer would approach shopping. The sportsbooks are selling their product, which are their main lines and props.
As we experience the dog days of summer, there are fewer sports to bet on, but warmer weather always means one thing: baseball takes center stage as the 2025 MLB season heads to the All-Star break and the Home Run Derby.
Speaking of home runs, nothing is more fun than betting on your favorite player to hit a dinger on a hot summer day. Adding another thing to root for in a game raises the viewing experience to another level.
If you want to bet on Aaron Judge hitting a home run today, the next step is to pull up the odds at various sportsbooks.
Similarly, why would you pay more money for the exact same burger at different restaurants? It doesn't make sense to reward the sportsbooks that have bad odds.
So, which sportsbook has the best odds when it comes to dingers? Dimers.com digs through the data to find out.
The Best Sportsbooks for Betting Home Runs
Sticking with my example of eating burgers at restaurants, similar to how not all restaurants are the same, not all sportsbooks are the same.
Sometimes, restaurants trade food quality for service or highlight the dine-in experience's atmosphere and ambiance over the food's quality. I've also experienced the flip side at different hole-in-the-wall restaurants, where the meal outshines the service tenfold.
The same thing is true with sportsbooks because not every sportsbook operates in the same way.
Do you bet home runs? 🤔
— Dimers.com (@DimersCom) July 13, 2025
Then you might wanna take a look at this 👀
Dimers intern @TonyParlay shows exactly why it's so important to have multiple sportsbooks when betting dingers this summer.
⚠️ Find bonus bets and offers in your state → https://t.co/yQetufJdJd pic.twitter.com/BhJ64Kt9FM
Some are easier to navigate than others, some are better for live betting, some are better at rewarding users with perks and promos, and some have better lines. Some are more difficult to deposit and withdraw your winnings from.
It's doubtful that one sportsbook can satisfy all your needs as a sports bettor. The bigger sportsbooks operate like buffet restaurants.
Buffets have pizza and burgers, but they're never as good as local pizza and burger joints.
After tracking the odds of hitting a home run for the top-10 leaders in baseball on a number of sports betting apps for a one week period, the results were quite interesting.
Best Home Run Odds Top 10 Players July 7-11
Sportsbook | #1 Odds Count | Avg. Rank (Across All Picks) |
---|---|---|
BetRivers | 16 | 2.26 |
Bet365 | 9 | 2.50 |
BetMGM | 6 | 2.98 |
DraftKings | 4 | 3.80 |
FanDuel | 6 | 3.88 |
Insights:
- BetRivers was the most competitive sportsbook, offering the best odds most frequently (16 times) and also achieving the lowest average rank.
- Bet365 was a close second, with solid performance in both frequency and consistency.
- FanDuel and DraftKings rarely had the best odds and were generally less competitive overall.
While BetRivers Sportsbook and bet365 led the way, when it came to a player such as Yankees slugger Aaron Judge, the variance from day-to-day was wild.
Aaron Judge Home Run Odds July 8-11
Date | FanDuel | DraftKings | BetMGM | CZR | Bet365 | BetRivers | Best Sportsbook | Best Odds |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
7/8/25 | +210 | +200 | +200 | +190 | +210 | +210 | FanDuel/Bet365 | +210 |
7/9/25 | +172 | +200 | +200 | +180 | +195 | +200 | DraftKings/BetMGM | +200 |
7/10/25 | +210 | +180 | +200 | +180 | +200 | +200 | FanDuel | +210 |
7/11/25 | +144 | +155 | +180 | +150 | +180 | +175 | BetMGM/Bet365 | +180 |
Refusing to Line Shop Is Setting Yourself up for Failure
Let’s go back to the burger analogy. If two restaurants sell the exact same burger, but one charges $8 and the other charges $12, which one are you choosing? It wouldn’t make sense to knowingly overpay—yet that’s exactly what many bettors do when they stick with a single sportsbook.
The truth is, sportsbooks count on you being loyal—or more accurately, complacent. They bank on the idea that once you’re signed up, have the app downloaded, and your payment method saved, you’ll prioritize convenience over value. And that gives them room to offer worse odds without fear of losing your business. I mean, it's no surprise that the two biggest sportsbooks in America in terms of market share ranked last and second-last for average home run odds, right?
MORE: Best MLB Props for Today
It’s not just about comfort, either. For many bettors, there's a psychological hurdle: switching books might feel like a hassle. Creating a new account, funding it, learning a new interface—it takes effort. But that’s exactly the kind of friction sportsbooks hope will keep you from shopping around.
This is why you should treat odds like prices. If you wouldn’t pay $12 for an $8 burger, you shouldn’t accept +180 odds on a home run when another book is offering +210. Over time, those seemingly small differences add up to big swings in your bankroll.
Different sportsbooks have different strengths. Some are cleaner to navigate, others more generous with promotions. Some shine in live betting, others in prop markets. But no single sportsbook consistently offers the best odds across the board.
Luckily, finding the best sportsbooks for odds and bonus offers is easy on the Dimers Best Betting Sites page. Find the best offer in your state and click through to sign up. The process is fast and easy for most sportsbooks with registration completed in less than a couple of minutes.
Responsible Gambling
Remember to please gamble responsibly. If you sense that you're taking your luck too far, know when to call it quits and don't be afraid to seek assistance. Keep in mind that gambling is all about having a fantastic experience! If you or someone you know is grappling with gambling issues, reach out to 1-800-GAMBLER for crisis counseling and support.